DC power management, replacement.

The Problem

I’ve mentioned in other posts the problems we’ve had over the years with the DC power panel located (in the 32SA) in the passenger rear compartment, next to the batteries.  This panel has the main battery cut-off switch, the Inverter DC power switch, four DC breakers for distributing power to various parts of the RV house and a hidden component the battery combiner relay.

The primary problem with this panel is the Inverter fuse which is a 1 by 1 by 3/4 DC power panelinch block mounted between the battery buss (leaving the main switch) and a buss bar that bolts to the back of the Inverter Switch.  Apparently, this bolt that holds that fuse between the two busses isn’t torqued properly and the design is such that heat builds up and the fuse insulation fails (adding to the problem).  As the fuse gets  hot, heat conducts up to the inverter switch and melts part of the switch until it fails.  There was even one report in facebook of this panel catching fire.

Recall

There is an NHTSA recall for this problem for various 2019 to 2022 models.  I personally don’t like the solution as covered in the recall.  If you have a 2000 watt inverter, the solution is to install a cable between the fuse and inverter switch (which won’t pipe heat directly up) as well as check the torque of the fuse bolt.  If you have a smaller inverter, they just check the fuse bolt torque.

I consider this panel to be a total fail.  In order to pull the panel to work on it, the only safe way is to disconnect the battery (usually recommended anyway) beause the support bracket comes very close to the main battery buss when removing the panel.  Fuses shouldn’t be buried behind panels.  The design of the fuse depends on a thin plastic insulator which fails as the fuse heats up which results in the bolt shorting the two busses which means there is no fuse.  Finally – the four DC circuit breakers are poorly supported and heavy wires are connected to them, also not supported/restrained, so sometimes just pulling the panel out and putting back in causes one of the breakers to physically break (happened to me once and also happened to a tech at Red Bay while he was replacing this panel).

The Replacement

The following describes MY solution.  I’m not recommending this for everyone.  It requires significant expense, tools and expertise most RVers would have issue with.

I designed a “replacement” for the
DC power components Tiffin/Lippert DC distribution panel.  It is all based on discrete components and thus takes up a lot more room.  It is amazing just how much stuff, Tiffin (Lippert) stuffed into that tiny panel – and not amazing why parts of the original panel failed so often.

Note:  some who are familiar with my story might say – you installed Lithiums and that overloaded the panel.  Nope.  Right out of the gate on our first trip, with the original Lead Acid batteries and original Magnum Inverter, anytime we used the inverter for a significant load (like the microwave), the inverter had fits and often shut down and the Spyder system rang a low voltage alarm.  We ended up using the generator any time we needed to cook.

When we started out with the lithiums – I checked the alternator rating: 150 amps.  I never saw the batteries charging from the engine more than 90 amps.  I believe this is because the lithiums were never mostly discharged.  We often used the generator when boondocking rather than the engine to charge.  One night we spent boondocking behind a restuarant.  We hit the road very early in the morning while still dark out after running the batteries down to below 40%.  As we took off, I looked at the charging rate and it was 120 amps into the batteries.  Add in headlights, heater fan and anything else – we had to be pushing the generator on the engine to its limit for the first hour.  I didn’t like pushing it that hard.  My solution was to install a Victron DC to DC battery charger.  This will limit the engine to house batteries to 30 amps, which is fine because we rarely need to charge up the house batteries quickly with the RV engine.  It should keep me from pushing the engine alternator so hard.

The Tiffin battery connect solenoid links the house and chassis batteries any time the engine is running or when the battery linking switch on the dash is depressed (also maybe when generator is running).  I didn’t want it connecting when the engine is running – the DC to DC charger takes care of that by monitoring the chassis battery voltage to determine when the engine is running.   I disabled the Tiffin logic by putting a switch between it and the solenoid.  Thus I can flip the switch and still use the dash switch to connect the batteries.  My inverter has a trickle charger to keep the chassis batteries topped off so I don’t need the generator function either.

Roughing it smoothly, right……

The second edition of my book is out.  Your RV is Broken is here on Amazon.

Roughing it smoothly.  Smoothly roughing it.  Wearing down the rough edges.  Designing (I won’t call it engineering) every day RVs, right to the rough edge…..

I saw a post in Facebook from someone with a similar melted fuse.  I responded with a comment and pointer to this upgrade/repair in facebook and found several other people that found themselves in the same “boat”.  A couple had the “melted” 400 amp fuse and the melted inverter switch.  One had his panel actually catch fire.  Fortunately, he was outside and saw it in time to get a fire extinquisher on it till the fire dept showed up.  His Insurance company fire investigator pointed to the inverter switch.  I had wondered if this problem was “just me” or because I upgraded my inverter (though all the parts claimed to be rated to be able to handle the load).  Now I see others are having the same problem with unmodified systems.  Spyder (not Lippert as I initially thought) SHOULD have some explaining to do as they are the source for these DC power panels.  

Back of power panel
Inverter switch at top. Three fuses below. Bus bar from right fuse to inverter has been removed in this picture
Back of DC power panel
This shows the “jumper cable” connected right to the inverter switch (separate 400 amp fuse not shown here).

After posting this, and someone people wondering about their own RVs with this panel, I thought I should provide some pointers on how people can check for trouble and/or have their checked for proper connections. One way to check your panel would be to first make sure you are putting some current through the inverter switch.  Either be charging your batteries from a partially discharged state via generator/camp plugin or by drawing a significant load from your inverter that is using batteries (no generator or camp plugin).  If you are pushing lots of current through your battery wiring or a distribution panel such as this, and there is a poor connection heat will be the result.  Get a temperature gun and first take a temperature down in the lower right corner to get a reference.  Then measure the transfer switch and the area beneath the switch (Inverter fuse in this panel right below the left side of switch).  If the temperature is more than a couple of degrees warmer, you might have a resistive connection.  If it is 20, 30, 40 degrees warmer you have a serious problem.  This test has general applications too beyond just this RV. Start with your battery connections and measure the temperature of each and every one.  Then follow cables as much as possible to switches and other high current components.  None of them should be significantly warmer than the ambient temperature.  If you find a hot spot and aren’t comfortable working with high current components then hire someone to check.  The torque specs are on the back of this panel.  If you remove this panel without disconnecting the battery be extra careful. The panel is mounted in a steel frame and the main bus is very close to that frame.  Its best to disconnect first.

If you are the techie type, this might be your excuse to get an infrared camera.  But seriously, every RV should have a temperature gun.  For this purpose, checking brakes, looking for air leaks, checking AC output, refrigerator and freezer temperatures, checking the asphalt temperature in Death Valley, hot springs in Yellowstone and on and on.

DC power panel
DC power panel
Facebook bad switch
From Facebook, another’s melted switch.
Burned up panel
From Facebook: another owner’s burned up Power Panel.

The story:  I just completed a major upgrade on my Tiffen Open Road 32SA.  I’ll call it an upgrade, not a repair, because in one way, having to go down this road is the result of other work I’ve done.

Let’s go back to the beginning.  We picked up our motorhome, November 2018.  Headed right for Red Bay for some repair work.

Then headed out west.  We ended up in Quartzite for what turned out to be a couple of months – including for the big tent sale.  We had been experiencing some low voltage warnings on our 2000W MagnaSine inverter.  We had to be careful what appliances we were running, or we’d end up resetting the MagnaSine.  We went to the big tent show and found a good sale price on four 100 amp-hour BattleBorn lithium batteries.  We swapped four of them in and they helped.  Certainly, let us run the generator for shorter periods of time.  I sold the lead acid batteries for about half price which made me and the buyer happy.

Solar and InverterEventually, we upgraded the 2k MagnaSine to a 3k Victron Multiplus along with 800 watts of solar.  Now we were cooking with electrons.  And we were, often using an air fryer, a cook pot or induction cook top.  We hate the propane stove that came with the RV.  Till one day when the inverter just quit.

Burnt Fuse and busbar
Burnt Fuse and busbar

I pulled out a meter and followed the zero volts path back to find the big red inverter power switch had failed – and traced that to a fuse that heated up the power bus so hot it melted the back of the inverter switch.  The fuse never blew, it just got hot.  There is a long post on this fiasco here.

I bypassed the errant fuse with a short cable and in-line fuse and the next time we were near Red Bay, we had them replace the entire distribution panel.  This panel has three of those one-inch square fuses and four pushbutton circuit breakers AND a solenoid to connect the chassis and house batteries when driving.  The four breakers are held in place with one screw with the other side poking out through the panel.  A heavy wire hangs off each one – with no strain relief.  The tech and Red Bay broke one of these breakers re-installing the panel.  This is a terrible design.  I believe those breakers are designed to be held in place on three if not four sides.

Deja Vu

Fragile breakers
Fragile breakers

So, back on the road and a few months later:  same thing.  The inverter switch burns up.

Fuse holder with burnt insulation
Fuse holder with burnt insulation

We were on a 30 amp campsite.  Normally, I tell the Victron inverter to not allow more than 15 amps through and it supplements any more draw than that from the battery.  But I forgot to his time.  We had three appliances running, plus the air conditioner and popped the campground 30 amp breaker.  The Victron says “I”ve got this, hold my beer!”.  The Victron will actually provide up to 5600 watts for a short period of time.  In this case it was somewhere around 30 seconds before the inverter switch gave up the ghost, again.  This time I had all the parts, so quickly bypassed the failed components, again.

Engineering Dreams

All of the Tiffin/Syder supplied parts are rated to carry that load – but obviously, they really aren’t.  At no time did I ever blow the 400 amp fuses, either of them. So, I started dreaming about a new distribution system, built out of discrete components.  I gathered parts and we looked for a window when we could actually make it happen.  I had to be really sure of my design and parts because getting in the middle of nowhere and quitting wasn’t an option because no DC power means no Spyder controls, no inverter, no air conditioning etc.

Today turned out to be the day.  I laid out the whole system on a pair of boards that I had planned to install on the bottom of the battery bay and the front wall.

New distribution
New distribution

I made all the cables custom for the layout.  But a last-minute discussion with my wife led to the decision to skip the wood.  So, everything was mounted right to the storage bin wall: sheet metal – probably safer.  A lot harder, but I could use the same layout and all the cables were ready to go.

By using discrete components, I can measure temperatures to monitor how things are working and replace any part or connection that fails relatively easily.  On my someday list are more lithium batteries and more solar and this is a design I can be confident will stand up to the punishment and I won’t have to wait in line for parts from Tiffin or Spyder.

DC components w/labels
DC components w/labels

To the left is the new distribution system with labels for all the components.  On the

Power diagram 32SA
Power diagram 32SA

right is a partial block diagram of the power distribution in the 32SA.  The green boxes are AC breakers in the bedroom.  As usual, clicking on any image will bring up a new window with a larger version.